Historical Albion Michigan
By Frank Passic

Return to the Frank Passic
Home Page  

Return to the Albion Michigan Home Page

Any photos not otherwise credited are from the personal collection of Frank Passic, Albion Historian.

TENNEY PEABODY DIED AT E. MICHIGAN AVENUE HOME

Morning Star, September 11, 2011, pg. 11.

I’ll be looking forward to meeting you at my Albion History Booth at the Festival of the Forks on Saturday, September 17 in front of Citizen’s Bank. I’ll have my Albion history books and materials for sale and autographing, so come on down. If you have old Albion photos and other materials, I’m always looking for new material for my articles here in this column.

Since this is Festival of the Forks week, let’s go way back to the beginnings of Albion history. Have you ever wondered in what house did Albion’s first settler, Tenney Peabody, die? Don’t worry, it wasn’t your house.

When Tenney Peabody came with his family in March, 1832 to "the Forks,” he first lived in a crude log cabin he constructed by E. Erie and. S. Monroe Sts. There is a faded State of Michigan historical marker (several of Albion’s older markers are now faded and need to be restored) located near the site today. Shortly thereafter, Mr. Peabody constructed a permanent block house just north of there in the same block on E. Porter St., across the street from the Presbyterian Church.

The Albion Recorder recalled that first settlement in March, 1886: "Fifty-four years ago today Charles Blanchard arrived in Albion in company with the late Tenney Peabody and a young man named Dowling. At the time there was not even a shanty or a clearing to mark the present site of this now beautiful and flourishing little city. They reached here about noon and devoted the remained of the day to preparing the ground for the erection of a cabin. The first night, the wagon afforded the only sleeping accommodation. When the cabin was completed the members of the family, who had been left at Blashfields six miles east, came on and thus formed the nucleus of the village. Mr. Blanchard says the weather was delightful and continued so through the spring months.”

Six years after living in "the first home,” Peabody then constructed a new large house at 1101 E. Michigan Ave. and moved his family there. This was a prominent structure which contained several large white pillars in the front. It was in this house that Tenney Peabody, Albion’s first settler, died on July 12, 1856 at the age of 63.

Within a year after Peabody’s death, the property was purchased by Methodist clergyman Rev. Andrew Mason Fitch (1815-1877). His name appears on the 1858 (drawn in 1857) Plat Map. Fitch Street was named after him. Fitch constructed a new elegant home on the site, and it is the Fitch (not Peabody) home that is pictured in the 1894 "Souvenir of City of Albion, Michigan In Photo-Gravure,” by James Field.

What happened to the Peabody house? Peabody’s house was moved across the street to the northeast corner of E. Perry and Park Sts. The 1890 Bird’s Eye View of Albion by Pauli shows a house on that corner with pillars.

Later after Mr. Fitch passed away, his house became the home of Albion College professor Delos Fall. It was in the back of that house where professor Fall rented a room to Rev. George Bennard, and where the famous hymn "The Old Rugged Cross” was composed in 1912. A State of Michigan historical marker is located in front of the site. In the 1920s the house became the home of the Delta Tau Delta fraternity, which stayed there until 1966. The house was then demolished.

From our Historical Notebook this week we present a painting of Albion’s first settler, Paul Tenney Peabody. Did you know that our town was almost named Peabodyville? Imagine having a Peabodyville College, and a football team, the Peapods here in town.


Paul Tenney Peabody (1793-1856)

Next: GWEN DEW's RECOLLECTIONS OF ALBION COLLEGE


Back to the Top of this Page

All text copyright, 2026 © all rights reserved Frank Passic  |  Artwork copyright Maggie LaNoue © 2026

Frank Passic Albion Historian Frank Passic — Albion Historian

An Albion native and 1971 graduate of Albion High School, Frank Passic has been researching and writing Albion history since 1976. He is the creator of the Albion Historical Notebook, with hundreds of articles appearing weekly in the Morning Star and The Recorder. Frank maintains an extensive personal archive including Riverside Cemetery records, family surname files, genealogies, photographs, city directories, and high school yearbooks. Support his 2026 research at the Historic Albion Michigan Facebook page.

Historical Notebook  |  From the Archives  |  Subject List  |  100 Years Ago  |  Alphabetical Index  |  Frank Passic Home Page  |  Albion History Books  |  Contact Frank
Michigan Prints by Maggie LaNoue Michigan Prints by Maggie LaNoue

Michigan Prints offers limited-edition archival Giclée prints, miniprints, notecards and boxed sets featuring Michigan landmarks, nature, resorts and nostalgia. Each print and card includes a legend on the back with stories about Michigan history. Albion scenes include the Kalamazoo River waterfall and the Blizzard of 1978. Find Michigan Prints online and at local shops.

Michigan Prints  |  Albion Scenes  |  Custom Cards  |  Zazzle Gifts
AlbionMich.net AlbionMich.net — General Guide to Albion

AlbionMich.net is a hub for community life in the greater Albion area, featuring current news, city council updates, river restoration stories, parks and trails. See Albion's beautiful Kalamazoo River waterfall as it looks today — and follow the story of its future restoration. Includes news from The Recorder and stories about Albion's 17 parks.

AlbionMich.net  |  Albion Blog  |  Frank Passic on AlbionMich.net
General Guide to Albion General Guide to Albion

AlbionMich.net offers two General Guides to the Albion area — one covering community life including city council, veterans, history, youth and wellness resources, and one covering the outdoors including roads, rivers, parks, trails and downtown. Both guides feature stories by local writers including contributors to The Recorder, sorted by topic for easy reference.

General Guide — Community  |  General Guide — Outdoors
Robin James Indices Unlimited Robin James — Indices Unlimited

Robin James is the editor of the Albion Historical Notebook and has kept Frank Passic's thousands of articles organized and searchable for decades. A trained librarian and archivist, Robin specializes in back-of-book and online indexing, multimedia collection management, and corporate information distribution. He also enjoys strange music and is a contributing editor for Igloo electronic music magazine.

For more about his indexing services, visit Indices Unlimited.
AlbionDesign.com — Communications Specialists Since 1981  |  Advertise on AlbionMich.com